It all seems to prove, as if there was any doubt, that mature, thinking believers and mature, thinking atheists are perfectly capable of getting along and having an interesting discussion. And it really wouldn't matter who "won"...

Frustrating as it can be to be an aetheist, I often think it must be much more anguishing to be a careful, thoughtful theologian working within some kind of meaningful hermeneutical tradition. Then the quick-fix "fundamentalists" would really drive you nuts.