Weird Psychiatry
Aug. 3rd, 2004 01:41 amAccording to this article, almost 15% of US residents have some sort of personality disorder, according to DSM criteria. Now, it has struck me for a while that the US seems to going a bit over the top on personality disorders - in fact, US psychiatry generally strikes me as being a bit faddish - and this isn't likely to dissuade me.
I obviously am neither a psychiatrist nor a psychologist, but those of you who are - does it seem reasonable to you to cast the net so widely? I know personality disorders aren't diseases, but presumably a lot (most?) of these people are adequately functional people.
Also, it immediately suggests a rewrite of the old joke about Parliament :
1. 15% of Americans have a personality disorder.
2. The US federal government has 100 Senators and 435 members of Congress.
The physics article looks intriguing also, but obviously I've no idea what it all means.
I obviously am neither a psychiatrist nor a psychologist, but those of you who are - does it seem reasonable to you to cast the net so widely? I know personality disorders aren't diseases, but presumably a lot (most?) of these people are adequately functional people.
Also, it immediately suggests a rewrite of the old joke about Parliament :
1. 15% of Americans have a personality disorder.
2. The US federal government has 100 Senators and 435 members of Congress.
The physics article looks intriguing also, but obviously I've no idea what it all means.